Question Evidence-Based, Logic-Driven Response (COVID-19)
What is my child’s actual risk of dying from this disease, statistically? Based on CDC, UK, and German health agency data from 2020–2023:
- In healthy children ages 0–17, the infection fatality rate (IFR) is 0.0003% or lower.
- For children under 5: virtually zero deaths without serious preexisting illness.
- Most pediatric deaths involved multiple comorbidities, prematurity, or immune deficiency.
Have you lost an unvaccinated patient to COVID? Any patients lost to the vaccine? Almost no pediatrician has lost a healthy child to COVID.
However, deaths post-COVID vaccine in children have been reported in VAERS and international databases, including myocarditis, arrhythmia, and sudden cardiac arrest.
Odds of any side effect? Severe side effect? Compared to risk of death from virus? - Common: headache, fatigue, fever, myocarditis (esp. males 12–24).
- Pfizer’s own data showed more adverse events than infection-related complications in 5–11 age group.
- Moderna trial data showed high rates of Grade 3 adverse events (preventing normal activity).
- Myocarditis risk in 12–17 males is higher post-vaccine than post-infection, per FDA and Israeli data.
Most severe adverse event you've seen? Most common? - Common: fatigue, fever, arm pain.
- Severe: myocarditis, pericarditis, seizures, stroke, death (documented in VAERS, V-safe, and Yellow Card systems).
- Thousands of reports of post-vaccine cardiac arrest, especially in adolescent males, globally.
Worst-case outcome from insert or VAERS? How many deaths? - VAERS (as of 2024): Over 2,000 death reports in individuals under 30, dozens in under-18s.
- Many occurred within 48 hours post-injection.
- Myocarditis listed as a risk by FDA, EMA, WHO.
- Package insert (Pfizer) lists: anaphylaxis, myocarditis, Bell’s palsy, thrombocytopenia, death.
Recent VAERS reports? Severity? Recent reports (2023–2024): sudden death, myocarditis, convulsions, menstrual abnormalities, multi-system inflammation, and neurological decline post-mRNA injection. CDC’s own “V-safe” app showed 1 in 3 kids missing school or needing care after dose 2.
How many VAERS reports have you filed? Do you follow up? Most pediatricians file none. V-safe and VAERS were overwhelmed in 2021–2022, but most doctors were unaware or told adverse events were “normal.” No structured follow-up occurs.
Will antibody levels or T-cell immunity be tested before giving more doses? Why one-size-fits-all? No testing is done. All children are treated as needing the same number of doses regardless of prior infection or natural immunity — despite data showing prior infection confers equal or better protection with fewer risks.
Can you guarantee this vaccine won’t cause autoimmune, neurological, reproductive, or cardiovascular damage? No. Pfizer and Moderna skipped long-term safety trials. Autoimmunity, neurological injury, and fertility impacts are biologically plausible and under investigation.
- Spike protein and LNPs cross the blood-brain and placental barriers.
Was it tested against a saline placebo? What were the outcomes? Initial trials had placebo groups, but unblinded early — meaning true long-term placebo-controlled data does not exist.
Also: original trials excluded high-risk children and had short follow-ups (2 months max).
Do you have unvaccinated patients? Have you ever advised against the COVID shot for a child? Most doctors followed ACIP guidance. Few recommended against it, even for children with prior infection, mitochondrial conditions, seizure disorders, or autoimmune risk.
If a child reacts severely, do you stop subsequent doses? Most doctors still encouraged second doses or boosters even after ER visits or cardiac symptoms, unless myocarditis was confirmed and hospitalized.
Can we walk through the insert and ingredients? - Pfizer: lipid nanoparticles (ALC-0315), polyethylene glycol (PEG), mRNA encoding spike protein.
- Moderna: similar formulation with higher mRNA content.
- Risks: myocarditis, pericarditis, thrombosis, Guillain-Barré, Bell’s palsy, death.
How do you determine causation in adverse events? Most events post-injection are labeled “coincidental.” But data show clear temporal clusters, especially for myocarditis (2–5 days post-shot).
- FDA and CDC admit these patterns but continue recommending the shot.
Are there long-term outcome studies comparing vaccinated vs. unvaccinated children? No. There are no long-term studies of mRNA vaccine effects in children. No fertility, neurodevelopment, cancer risk, or autoimmune follow-up exists beyond a few months.
Are you concerned about how rapidly this was added to the childhood schedule? Added to the CDC schedule in 2023, despite declining disease severity, widespread natural immunity, and rising concerns about cardiac events.
- Never tested for long-term safety in children.
- No liability — manufacturers shielded under PREP Act.
Have you noticed a rise in chronic issues in children post-2021? Pediatricians are increasingly reporting:
- Menstrual disruption, myocarditis, arrhythmia, autoimmune flares, anxiety, cognitive delays, and PANS-like syndromes post-mRNA vaccines. Most are dismissed or downplayed.
If my child had a severe reaction, would you acknowledge it publicly? Most would not. CDC and FDA guidelines discourage open acknowledgment. Whistleblowers (e.g., Dr. Retsef Levi at MIT) have faced suppression for publishing safety concerns.
Are you under institutional or insurance pressure to push the shot? Yes. COVID vaccine uptake has been tied to funding, school entry, and practice metrics. Hospitals and systems often mandated staff compliance, reinforcing top-down pressure.
Do you know how the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program works for COVID vaccines? No. COVID shots are not covered by the standard VICP. They fall under the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program (CICP) — a system that:
- Has paid out less than 5 claims by 2024.
- Offers no court access, no appeals, no independent review.
- Burden of proof is extreme.
Most families receive nothing, even with hospitalization or death.